Furnace Drain Holes---Procedure for use?

Discussion in 'Furnaces and their construction' started by Melterskelter, Nov 1, 2017.

  1. Melterskelter

    Melterskelter Gold Banner Member

    I have noticed several mentions of furnace drain holes placed in the base of melting furnaces. The idea makes sense. But I also note that the holes are usually plugged with blanket or compressed refractory board.

    So, my question is: In the event of a crucible rupture that presumably dumps a fair bit of molten metal into the furnace, how do you locate and open the hole so the metal can drain out before it cools?

    I am casting my furnace hotface sides tomorrow. I already drilled a 1" hole in the base of the hotface locating it off center about 4 inches which should clear the base of a plinth.

    Melter.
     
    Last edited: Nov 1, 2017
  2. Jason

    Jason Gold

    This one almost deserves a poll. I have a hole, but keep it plugged with kaowool. I suppose if I had a breach, I could take a piece of rebar and stick it through the hole and push out the kaowool.
    I can tell you, my next furnace build will not have a hole. If you ever have to question the integrity of your crucible, then you probably shouldn't be using it. Fair enough?
     
  3. Tobho Mott

    Tobho Mott Administrator Staff Member Banner Member

    I just let the drain in mine spit flames. I keep a rusty old worn out muffin pan down there to keep it from making the middle of the cart sag when it gets red hot. Good place to preheat my dross-skimming tool. Some people plug the hole with a ball of aluminum foil, the idea being that it would melt out in case of a spill.

    Jeff
     
  4. Melterskelter

    Melterskelter Gold Banner Member

    Thanks for the above replies:
    The rebar and blind poking to open the hole is what I imagined, but that seemed like a chancy scenario. And just venting the hole seemed like an energy sink.

    You can be sure that I do not intend to use a crucible if it's integrity is in doubt, but, then, I have heard of surprise failures. That's the point of this precaution, I suppose.

    Given the high temperatures expected in a furnace interior how could aluminum foil not melt out with every use?

    Melter
     
    Last edited: Nov 2, 2017
  5. Tobho Mott

    Tobho Mott Administrator Staff Member Banner Member

    That is why I just let mine spit fire - my tin foil ball had disappeared by end of melt when I tried that trick one time. I think it was J. Vibert who was using the foil ball trick. Our different results might have to do with having different sizes of drainage holes/channels. Just guessing though...

    Jeff
     
  6. Al2O3

    Al2O3 Administrator Staff Member Banner Member

    I have a drain hole in my furnace and would do it again, and my smaller furnace is electric. I use clay graphite crucibles for my aluminum castings but have a steel crucible I use for utility things like melting lead. Here's my experience so far:

    I have a about a 1" drain hole in center of the furnace basin and four shallow troughs that lead to it so the plinth can sit flat in the center of the furnace base. I had stuffed a wad of ceramic wool in there and frankly had forgotten about it. I was melting wheel weights to make some machine ballasts. Because of the wetting properties of lead (and probably tin and other things in wheel weights...think solder), it identified a pin hole in the weld at the base of the crucible not visible to my eye nor had it revealed itself in other melts. In addition to capillary action, with lead there is plenty of head pressure to drive the leak.

    Before I noticed it I had a five pound pool of molten lead in the bottom of my furnace. When I removed the crucible and plinth and went to poke the wad of wool out the bottom, to my surprise, I could not because the lead had frozen at the bottom of the 3" long drain hole and refused to melt through because it was far enough through the insulted refractory that it was no where near furnace temps. I ended up having to let the furnace cool, drill it, and then re-fire the furnace to drain the lead while poking with a hot rod. I have since just left the drain open.

    Sometimes after resizing casting stock it still doesn't fit entirely within the crucible or just when stacked high. On a second occasion I must have had a piece of stock shift or slump and fall out of the crucible. It melted on the floor of the furnace and ran out the drain hole. My ingot trays store below the drain hole. I didn't even know it had happened until the next time I removed the ingot tray for use and found the resulting small ingot laying in the tray.

    Careless or Murphy's law? Stuff happens. You can always plug the hole with wool. It's much harder to make a drain hole in refractory after the fact.

    Best,
    Kelly
     
  7. OCD

    OCD Silver

    Yep, I'm another for drain holes.
    Nope, no plug either.
    I've never noticed any flames shooting out the hole either.

    Murphy's Law!

    When ever I do end up with a crucible failure in the future (and it will happen sooner or later) one less thing I have to worry about is cleaning the bottom of the furnace out and possibly replacing some of the refractory.

    [​IMG]
     
  8. Tobho Mott

    Tobho Mott Administrator Staff Member Banner Member

    I believe my drain is 1.5" for the record. I went maybe a little big because in my old furnace I didn't make it big enough and it froze shut the first time I burned through a steel crucible with charcoal furnace blower overkill. I've since wondered if maybe it was the fact I kept the charcoal suspended a couple inches off the floor and having just blower air down there that kept the hole cool rather than it being too small that made it freeze. Not planning on holing out any more crucibles, but maybe I'll try direct melting something large (but not so large I need to drag out my wheel melter barrel) some day. I definitely know for sure my drain hole isn't cold anymore...

    Jeff
     
    Last edited: Nov 2, 2017
  9. cactusdreams

    cactusdreams Copper Banner Member

    My small propane tank furnace started with a 3/4" offset drain plugged from the bottom with a wad of foil. Put to the test from clumsiness or too much degasser it clogged up. Note: if you clog your drain, poke it out while still hot and molten with a steel rod. So I bore the hole to 1" and put a layer of hd foil over the bottom of the drain tube. It melted from just normal use and a huge amount of fire shot out. Two layers did the trick. It melts when needed but not before. I use copper foil for melting brass and bronze.
     
  10. Melterskelter

    Melterskelter Gold Banner Member

    How do you secure the foil/hold it in place? I'll be melting iron, so, likely copper foil will be the ticket. Where do you get it?

    Melter
     
  11. OCD

    OCD Silver

    David has a Butt Plug he'd be more than happy to send ya.

    Think it may have been used though before he got it. :eek:
    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Nov 2, 2017
  12. cactusdreams

    cactusdreams Copper Banner Member

    Simple but effective.

    Cu foil cap.jpg

    I found this at an art supply store. It's used for embossing. This was the thinnest they had.

    Cu foil roll.jpg
     
  13. OCD

    OCD Silver

    Lowe’s has really thin 6” x 6” sheets of copper and a few other metals in their hardware section.
    It’s in the drawers where all the weird stuff is.
     
    Melterskelter likes this.
  14. HT1

    HT1 Gold Banner Member

    your furnace needs a drain or several inches of sand in the bottom, you are going to get metal in the bottom of your furnace sooner or later unless you are some sort extreme perfectionist. My current furnace probably has 10 Lbs of metal in the bottom that is never coming out just from splashes from overfilling and dropped slag from skimming .

    V/r HT1
     
  15. DavidF

    DavidF Administrator Staff Member Banner Member

    Listen to what Train man says at 3:25.... LOL
     
  16. Melterskelter

    Melterskelter Gold Banner Member

    Thanks for the ideas. Good stuff.

    I am thinking it might not be too hard to incorporate a "poker" on a lever that could pass under the furnace and could be used to pop up/out a plug or perforate copper foil should a spill occur. Sounds like it is worthwhile to figure something out.

    Hope to cast my hot face sides tomorrow or early next week.

    Denis
     
  17. J.Vibert

    J.Vibert Silver

    Pro drain here... Can't wrap my head around why someone wouldn't want to take the small amount of extra time during a furnace build to include it. I also don't plan on needing the safety provided by foundry PPE, but I wear it anyway. In my very short experience, my drain doesn't hinder my furnace's performance. That said, I don't have any numbers to back that up. Just the ability to melt everything I've tried thus far. If someone was struggling to reach an internal temp, then I could see a drain being a problem causer... but then you could still plug it up...lol. The one time you need it, you'll be thankful it's there.

    The never mentioned benefit of the drain is being able to direct melt into ingot trays.

    I use the tin foil ball thing mentioned earlier to seal it off. Not that you need to. Just the practice I follow. Spills would follow the channels within the floor, under the plinth, and melt the tinfoil plug out.

    I used a piece of 1" pvc electrical conduit to form the drain. I'm going to guess that gives me a ~1.5 hole.
     
    Last edited: Nov 7, 2017
  18. Jason

    Jason Gold

    I tried the tin foil ball. Melted it. I find with the hole plugged, I get a more complete burn of my LIQUID! I wonder if this is a diesel/WMO vs propane thing. With my hole open, After 30mins or so, I end up with fluid on fire coming out that damn hole. With it plugged with kaowool, no more fluid, no more fire. After it's shut down, I lift up the plinth and everything is nice and dry.

    As long as I burn oil, no hole. Mine was made with a 1in PVC pipe that I torched out when the refractor was dry. Stinky stinky, hate the smell of burning pvc.
     
  19. Negativ3

    Negativ3 Silver

    I plan on burning propane/oil/diesel, shell without a drain. If a crucible fails, I would rather the contents remain inside the furnace body. To me it's more controlled.
     
  20. PatJ

    PatJ Silver

    I don't use drains in my furnaces.
    If I ever spilled aluminum in a furnace, I would probably turn it on its side and train the burner into the interior to melt/drain it.

    For an iron spill, I am not sure it would drain out the hole anyway; I guess it would if it were at pour temperature, but not all of it.

    To prevent spills, I use quality crucibles (Morgan salamander super), use lifting tongs that have a stop on them so as to limit pressure on the sides of the crucible, and don't jam the metal into the crucible where it cannot expand when hot.

    Before use, I tap on a crucible lightly to make sure it makes a ringing sound.
    If it makes a dull sound, it may be cracked.
     
    Last edited: Nov 9, 2017

Share This Page